According To Smoky
Welcome to According to Smoky. Here you will find the latest and greatest from C. Clark "Smoky" Hale notable 'baster', author, publisher, television star in both the barbecue and 'the real' world. And yes, he is a real person and not the webmaster.
Smoky will be offering his talents, techniques and secrets discovered over the last 150 years, or so. He will be to the point, pull no punches and if you suffer through the process, you will become a much better outdoor cook, turning out masterpiece meals for friends and family alike.
In this column, Smoky takes to the woods in search of the different types of woods available to the outdoor cook for preparing some great tasting wood smoke-cooked entrees. Hope this helps you folks! . . . . . take notes!
So, with no further adieu, we turn the mike to Smoky. You're on Smoky . . . . .
Thanks PC,
OUTDOOR COOKING WITH SMOKY HALE

By: Smoky Hale
Interest in the characteristics of particular woods has, traditionally,
been confined to wood workers and their clientele and those folk who heat
with wood. Except for MacBeth's fate resting upon whether or not Great
Birnham wood came up the "high Dunsinane hill" (Act IV, Scene I),
particular woods have never seemed like a life or death situation. But,
lately, with all the smoke blowing going on, the fad for cooking over
exotic woods and the extravagant claims of smoke blowers has reached
outrageous proportions.
As more and more people are learning, meat cooked in the smoke stream of
burning wood gets marred with all the cresols and phenols and other noxious
volatiles which make good wood preservatives but don't taste very good -
even to an unskilled palate. Since early time, even primitive man with
primitive palate learned that food tastes better cooked over coals than
over flames and smoke.
Besides unbounded enthusiasm spurred by abject ignorance, what has
permitted this travesty to good taste to even start has been the growth of
the horizontal cooker with an offset firebox. When meat was cooked directly
over the coals/fire, the results of flames and wood smoke were immediately
apparent to even the dullest tongue. Even users of the tin can water
smokers quickly deduce that it is very easy to turn an otherwise fine
piece of meat into a mummified creosote fossil.
In the sidewinder cookers, the heated air, however baffled and directed,
still flows in strata according to the temperature. This means that the
hotter air flows up to the top of the cooking chamber and out the stack
without necessarily coming in contact with the meat on the grate. Although
some cookers are designed so that the heated must exit below the meat, the
flow is up and over, rather than under, around and through, so that the
meat does not normally come into intimate contact with grossly excessive
smoke. Rather, as the smoke cools, some of it is deposited on the sides of
the cooker and builds up layers of creosote. This shiny black, acrid layer
is an indication of an inexperienced cook. Sometimes, however, even this
serendipitous air flow can not prevent way too much smoke being deposited
on the meat.
Regardless of the species of wood, too much smoke is offensive. It is
truly amazing that those whose palates do not rebel at creosote
contaminated meat are the same ones who claim that they can discern the
flavor of grape leaves, wine barrel French oak, Mackintosh apple or June
berry. Fact is that, except for a few wood species, such as hickory and
mesquite, less that 5% of the palates in the world can tell what kind of
wood was used to cook.
It's time we clear the air with some facts.
Five Reasons why wood coals are superior to flaming wood for cooking:
|
| 1. Green woods are 20-40% water. This must be boiled off before the wood
can burn. This means that BTUS (British Thermal Units - a measure of heat)
are used to boil water rather than to cook. |
| 2. Dry wood still has 8-12% moisture and contains many compounds which
must be cooked out - absorbing BTUs - before the temperature can rise. |
| 3. As long as there are moisture and volatiles to boil out, the
temperature cannot rise above the boiling point of the substances.
Therefore, in order to reach broiling temperatures - 5-700 degrees - all
the moisture and volatiles must be driven out. At that point the wood
becomes embers/coals. |
| 4. Successful broiling - steaks, burgers, chops - requires high radiant
heat. Flames of burning wood do not generate radiant heat at temperatures
as high as live embers. |
| 5. In the hours' long cooking periods, such as roasting and barbecuing,
the smoke flavor in the wood coals is more than ample. Anytime that you see
a full plume of smoke coming out of a barbecue cooker, you know that the
cook in making a serious error. |
Useful Common wood species.
Almost any hardwood makes very good coals for cooking. Normally, the
denser the wood, the more lignin, and, therefore, more BTUs per cubic volume.
Most common, in alphabetical order:
Apple/Pear, ash, beech, birch, butternut/walnut, cherry, hickory/pecan,
maple, oak.
Regional and miscellaneous:
Mesquite, alder, citrus, any edible fruit, nut or berry, persimmon,
sassafras, gum, pimiento, grape leaves and vines, hackberry, elm, chestnut,
bay.
Questionable:
China berry/mahogany, Osage orange, teak, tung, madrone, buckeye
Definitely don't.
Poison Oak, Poison Sumac, Oleander, pine and other resinous woods.
Flavor quotient for common woods suitable for
broiling, roasting and
barbecuing
Hickory, and to a lesser degree, its cousin the pecan, are powerful
flavoring woods. A little goes a long way. The wood makes great coals. When
barbecuing or roasting, I use about 20% hickory and 80% oak/apple/etc.
Mesquite has a potent flavor that some like and many dislike. I am of the
latter group. The wood makes excellent coals for broiling and, used in this
manner, does not overpower the meat flavor and become offensive.
Oak is the wood most commonly used for outdoor cooking. It imparts
excellent flavor without becoming too strong with normal cooking
techniques. Oak is outstanding for broiling or barbecuing. I prefer white
over red, but use them interchangeably.
Fruit woods - apple, pear, quince, cherry, etc and maple, beech, birch and
ash are mild flavored excellent choices for barbecuing and make excellent
coals for broiling.
Alder, mulberry, citrus, willow are mild flavored woods that are excellent
for fish, poultry and seafood. They are softer woods and therefore do not
make as potent embers as the harder woods.
Sassafras, bay and pimiento produce identifiable flavors which some might
find intrusive. Use sparingly until you are familiar with the taste.
If you live in a deforested area without easy access to wood, using an
insipid charcoal and want to spruce up (just kidding - spruce is a no-no)
the flavor for broiling, try the following. Bring the coal bed up to proper
temp. - 5-700 degrees - and add a mere handful of green wood chips or small
limbs, or wood chunks soaked for a couple of hours or sawdust soaked
likewise. Wait until the smoke is intense and the temperature has returned
to the proper level. Plop on the meat and close the lid - with good draft
top and bottom. In a couple of minutes, turn the steak/burger and close the
lid again. You should have plenty of smoke flavor. Beware that the meat
will cook quicker with the lid closed. Don't over cook.
For roasting and barbecuing under the same circumstances, the cheapest
route is to go in with a few friends and buy a cord (4'x4'x8') of dry
hardwood. Then you can burn down some wood for the coals while it is
heating up the grill. You wont need to add any smoke flavor.
Lacking that opportunity, when the grill is ready to start cooking, toss in
a double handful of wood, as above, throw on the meat and close the lid. Do
that once again in about 30 minutes. That is probably all the smoke flavor
that you need, but if you have become hooked on cresote, you can do it one
more time. Beyond that, the meat has sealed and will absorb no more smoke
flavor. Smoke will, however, continue to pile up on the outside with bitter
results.
It is my studied opinion that if the would-be cook spent at least half as
much time learning technique as he did chasing exotic fuel, he would be a
10 times better cook. For those mathematically inclined that formula is
[1/2a + 1/2b=110 ]
And that ain't just blowing smoke.
Good gobblin'
© 1998 by Smoky Hale
Smoky
C. Clark Hale
8168 Hwy 98 E.
McComb, MS 39648
 Smoky's 5th basic position for really great barbecue'n.
Return to Smoky's Columns
'According to Smoky' is © by C. Clark Hale
who is solely responsible for its content. Comments
should be addresses to cchale@bellsouth.net
|